On Tuesday, the New York Times ran a brief article, “College Presidents Defend Rising Tuition, but Lawmakers Sound Skeptical,” (9/9/08, A18) that inquired into the question, “Should colleges be required to spend more of their endowments?” Of course they should is the only logical answer. It all seems so reasonable. Together Harvard and Yale are sitting on endowments of approximately $60 billion. Universities earned an average of 17.2 percent on their assets but spent less than 5 percent. And they are tax exempt! Does this make any sense? The average tax payer is subsidizing universities with billions of dollars in assets.
One of the clearest indications that these elite colleges are just scamming the public are the comments from the wealthy universities that if they were required to spend a certain portion of their endowments, it would “interfere with their ability to manage economic downturns.” Surely these people must think we’re idiots if they expect us to swallow that level of argument. What kind of economic downturns would pose problems for universities with billions of dollars earning double digit interest?
This is not to say that colleges should not have large endowments but it is to say that if they have endowments in the billions, they should spend a substantial portion for the general good and they should not be tax exempt. After all, why should every citizen in this country subsidize universities that have assets of 10, 20, and 30 billion dollars? It just doesn’t make sense.
Showing posts with label college endowments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college endowments. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Thursday, March 13, 2008
Endowments and Free Tuition
Well, Brown University has joined the list of those elite colleges—like Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and Dartmouth—in “reducing” tuition. Students whose parents earn less than $60,000 annually will have free tuition and those whose parents earn less than $100,000 will receive grants (rather than loans). These 5 Universities, btw, have a combined endowment of $57 billion. And this is in addition to the real estate, equipment, publishing contracts, government grants, and whatever else they own. And so I want to ask 2 simple questions:
1. How many students will this help? How many current students at Brown, for example, have parents earning under $60,000? Is there anyone from Brown who’d like to respond? I suspect the answer would be zero or at least very close to that. If I’m wrong, Brown University, please correct me.
2. How much money will these schools be “giving up”?
The media are reporting these seemingly grand gestures but they don’t mention any specific numbers or amounts.
This is very similar to the advertisements that try to get you to buy their product by saying they’ll donate a portion of the purchase price to breast cancer research or to help abandoned dogs and cats. But, how much will be given to these causes is never spelled out—at least not in the ads I’ve seen. And so I’d like to know and to see in the ad, exactly how much money will be given to charity. Further, I would expect that a responsible charity would demand that an advertiser list the exact amount it will donate. But, then, I suspect, the charity would receive nothing. A sad situation.
Shouldn’t the organizations concerned with accuracy in advertisements and communication generally (like NCA and ICA, for example) be concerned with this kind of deceptive advertising—and I think it’s deceptive not because it makes any false claims but because it is designed to mislead people into believing that the amount to be denoted is significant when it likely isn’t (though I may be just overly negative here). Publishing principles for ethical communication—as NCA and ICA do—is a step in the right direction but certainly not sufficient for the premier organizations in communication. NCA and ICA and related organizations would serve a valuable service by pointing out such deceptions and raising public awareness.
1. How many students will this help? How many current students at Brown, for example, have parents earning under $60,000? Is there anyone from Brown who’d like to respond? I suspect the answer would be zero or at least very close to that. If I’m wrong, Brown University, please correct me.
2. How much money will these schools be “giving up”?
The media are reporting these seemingly grand gestures but they don’t mention any specific numbers or amounts.
This is very similar to the advertisements that try to get you to buy their product by saying they’ll donate a portion of the purchase price to breast cancer research or to help abandoned dogs and cats. But, how much will be given to these causes is never spelled out—at least not in the ads I’ve seen. And so I’d like to know and to see in the ad, exactly how much money will be given to charity. Further, I would expect that a responsible charity would demand that an advertiser list the exact amount it will donate. But, then, I suspect, the charity would receive nothing. A sad situation.
Shouldn’t the organizations concerned with accuracy in advertisements and communication generally (like NCA and ICA, for example) be concerned with this kind of deceptive advertising—and I think it’s deceptive not because it makes any false claims but because it is designed to mislead people into believing that the amount to be denoted is significant when it likely isn’t (though I may be just overly negative here). Publishing principles for ethical communication—as NCA and ICA do—is a step in the right direction but certainly not sufficient for the premier organizations in communication. NCA and ICA and related organizations would serve a valuable service by pointing out such deceptions and raising public awareness.
Wednesday, October 10, 2007
College Endowments
It seems from recent reports that some of the largest fortunes are owned not merely by Bill Gates and Warren Buffet but by colleges and universities throughout the country. For example, Harvard University leads the list and has an endowment of $28 billion; Yale is second with $18 billion, Stanford is third with $14 billion, and the University of Texas is fourth and Princeton is fifth, each with a little more than $13 billion. Rounding out the top ten are MIT, Columbia, University of California, University of Michigan, and Texas A&M. Despite these enormous bank accounts, colleges pay no taxes. The people who work for them--cleaning the hallways, serving in the cafeterias, and running the physical plant, for example—pay taxes (often on minimum or near-minimum wages) but the university itself pays none. This is not to say that colleges should pay taxes—although if those with these large endowments did pay, it would ease the tax burden on every other US citizen—but rather to illustrate the sweet deal they have.
In contrast Bill Gate’s fortune is estimated at $56 billion and Warren Buffet’s at $52 billion—admittedly more than even Harvard and Yale. But, consider what these fortunes are used for. Gates has established the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (now estimated at around $33 billion) which has contributed enormously to global health and research. And Warren Buffet has pledged close to $31 billion to the Gates foundation.
Given the example set by these two individuals—who, admittedly, are not typical—we need ask what these universities—also not typical—with endowments in the billions are doing with their money. As far as I can tell, they are doing very little other than investing it for growth (Harvard’s investments grew at a rate of 16.7% this last year while Yale’s grew at a rate of 17.2%) and running campaigns to raise still more money.
With a large part of the world starving, lacking clean water, and suffering from diseases (many of which could be prevented with adequate medical treatment), it seems that these universities have an obligation to pitch in and help out the rest of the world. What are these universities waiting for before they spend some of their money? Are they guarding against inflation (even though they raise tuition at a rate far in excess of the rate of inflation)? The world would be a lot better, to take one simple example, if just the five universities with the largest endowments gave half their fortunes to charity (a total of $43 billion), death from preventable illnesses could likely be made history throughout the world. These universities would still have enough for their day-to-day operation. I suspect that Harvard could easily get along with an endowment of only $14 billion and Yale could manage to eke out an existence with only $9 billion.
And to relate this just a bit to communication: Very few people seem to ask the question of what a college's responsibility is and what purpose these enormous endowments serve. I suspect people don't question this because these schools are expert communicators--their PR is unquestionably among the best in the world.
In contrast Bill Gate’s fortune is estimated at $56 billion and Warren Buffet’s at $52 billion—admittedly more than even Harvard and Yale. But, consider what these fortunes are used for. Gates has established the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (now estimated at around $33 billion) which has contributed enormously to global health and research. And Warren Buffet has pledged close to $31 billion to the Gates foundation.
Given the example set by these two individuals—who, admittedly, are not typical—we need ask what these universities—also not typical—with endowments in the billions are doing with their money. As far as I can tell, they are doing very little other than investing it for growth (Harvard’s investments grew at a rate of 16.7% this last year while Yale’s grew at a rate of 17.2%) and running campaigns to raise still more money.
With a large part of the world starving, lacking clean water, and suffering from diseases (many of which could be prevented with adequate medical treatment), it seems that these universities have an obligation to pitch in and help out the rest of the world. What are these universities waiting for before they spend some of their money? Are they guarding against inflation (even though they raise tuition at a rate far in excess of the rate of inflation)? The world would be a lot better, to take one simple example, if just the five universities with the largest endowments gave half their fortunes to charity (a total of $43 billion), death from preventable illnesses could likely be made history throughout the world. These universities would still have enough for their day-to-day operation. I suspect that Harvard could easily get along with an endowment of only $14 billion and Yale could manage to eke out an existence with only $9 billion.
And to relate this just a bit to communication: Very few people seem to ask the question of what a college's responsibility is and what purpose these enormous endowments serve. I suspect people don't question this because these schools are expert communicators--their PR is unquestionably among the best in the world.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)