Saturday, November 10, 2012

Product Placement Exercise


The recent release of Skyfall and the news that Heineken spent $45 million dollars to have James Bond drink its beer makes a perfect introduction to the issue of product placement. The following is a brief discussion of product placement and an exercise I developed for the artifactual communication chapter in my nonverbal communication book—still in manuscript. I thought this might be useful to those teaching the nonverbal communication course or a unit in an introductory course.

In much the same way that we make judgments about people on the basis of the products they use (jewelry, furs, and name brands from Prada to Old Navy), we also make judgments about products on the basis of the people who use them, a tendency that has spawned huge product placement efforts by major corporations. Product placement refers simply to the placement of a product—for a fee but without any explicit advertising statements—within a scene of a movie or television show to give it a certain image. The advertiser’s hope is that you’ll identify with the actor using the product (that is, you want to be like the character, in some ways) and that you too will then also buy the product. The actor and the movie give the product an image that the advertiser assumes will help sell the product.

In the 2012 James Bond Skyfall, for example, Heineken paid $45 million to have Bond drink its beer (New York Daily News, November 9, 2012). In addition, Bond wears a Tom Ford suit and an Omega watch while Q uses a Sony Vaio—all very clear to the viewer. Another Bond film, however, holds the record for product placements; the 1997 Tomorrow Never Dies earned $100 million for its product placements. The same is true on television; the Cheesecake Factory on The Big Bang Theoryand McDonald’s on 30 Rock are good examples. Product placement is, of course, nothing new; recall James Bond’s Aston Martin in the 1964 Goldfinger and E.T. eating Reese’s Pieces in the 1982 E. T. The Extra-Terrestrial.

As you no doubt already know, product placement is occurring in television sitcoms and dramas and in feature films with ever increasing frequency. That fact that this type of advertising aims to influence you subliminally raises all sorts of serious ethical issues. Those who favor or defend product placement, such as the American Advertising Federation argue:

Product placement is a legitimate source of advertising revenue and is not deceptive. It benefits both content producers and consumers and adds verisimilitude to fictional programming. We oppose proposals that would require simultaneous “pop up” notices of every instance of product placement, believing this would make television unwatchable. We instead believe the current practice of disclosures at the end of the program works well.

Those who oppose product placement argue that it’s deceptive because viewers are not aware that it’s a paid advertisement. It is subliminal advertising—messages that somehow get communicated without mindfulness or awareness. And, despite the AAF’s statement, no one can really read the disclosures at the end of a television program, nor would anyone want to. Further, the enormous profits to be made from product placement will likely lead to its spread to news shows which will further erode fairness and objectivity.

Regardless of the possible ethical violations, product placement is likely to remain a part of movies and television; it is too lucrative a market for it to disappear any time soon.

 
Product Placement

To sensitize you to the many ways in which advertisers try to influence you below the level of conscious awareness—and in effect counteract the influence of product placement—consider this exercise on product placement, another aspect of space decoration. During the next movie you watch—there are lots more in movies than in television shows—identify any product placements you notice and fill in the remaining columns of the accompanying table. The example provided will clarify the parts of this exercise.

 

Movie: ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­__________________________________________________.  Year: _______.

 

Product
How was the product used? What’s the context?
Intended meaning
Burger King hamburger bag
Iron Man Tony Stark wants an American hamburger before anything else
Burger King is the hamburger of choice, especially when you’re dying for one
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 

Thursday, November 8, 2012

50 Communication Strategies


I’ve assembled (and rewrote) some of my blog posts and a variety of other brief pieces into a book that I published with iUniverse, a subsidy publisher (recently acquired by Penguin, a division of Pearson), called 50 Communication Strategies. One of the advantages of publishing a book this way was that I didn’t need an agent. Textbook authors rarely have agents; in fact, I don’t know of one textbook author who does have an agent. The other great advantage is that you don’t have to write a proposal. There are also disadvantages to doing a book this way as well. But, on balance, the procedure was relatively painless and certainly fast moving.  They even set up a website for the book—www.50communicationstrategies.com. In general, I'm very pleased with the finished product.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

Self-Confidence


 
http://www.nannypro.com/blog/12-ways-to-help-your-child-gain-confidence/

Here’s a neat little list on ways to build confidence in a child, sent to me by the author, Sara Dawkins. Among the suggestions are:

  • Encourage independence
  • Praise the process, not the product
  • Applaud safe risk taking
  • Show unconditional love
  • Be a self-confident role model
  • Foster an “I can” attitude

With just a little tweaking this list is relevant to a wide variety of topics we talk about in interpersonal communication, e.g., self-esteem, empowerment, relationship development. Nor is the list limited in application to children—much of it (again, with a little tweaking) can be applied to the workplace and the classroom.

Monday, October 8, 2012

Gay History


 

Yesterday, TCM ran Night and Day, the biopic of Cole Porter. In it Cary Grant plays the famed songwriter/composer Cole Porter and Alexis Smith plays his loving wife. Apart from whatever merits or lack of them that this movie possessed, it’s a great example of how gay people are robbed of their history. Cole Porter was gay but this is never shown; instead you see a heterosexual male deeply in love with his wife. It’s a good example of how the media—at least in the 40’s but into the 21stcentury as well, contributed (along with political, religious, and social institutions) to deny gay people a legitimacy, a presence, a history. 

Also yesterday, the New York Times ran an article on “Helping a Child to Come Out” (http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/07/fashion/helping-a-gay-child-to-come-out.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0), perhaps an indication of how much society has progressed, perhaps an indication of how little society has changed.

            Among the interesting things pointed out in the article are these:

1.      Gay teens have higher rates of alcohol and drug abuse, depression, and suicide than their heterosexual counterparts. Helen Kahn, the director of the Family Project of the Human Rights Campaign, attributes this to the stress of being different, of being stigmatized and the problems that come with reactions from “friends” and family.

2.      Despite the attendant difficulties of coming out, one survey found that closeted gay children had an even harder time than those who did come out. Those who came out were significantly happier than those who remained in the closet.

3.      Parents need to listen to their children—often between the lines—so that they can help the child come out in his or her own time. Parents also need to show that their love is unconditional, that the home is a safe place where the child can discuss anything.

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Nonverbal Communication Project

Here is exercise that I'm working on for a nonverbal book I'm doing that I thought might be useful. It contains just a few general instructions for creating a video and lots of video examples. Although most clearly directed at the nonverbal course, I thought this might also be appropriate in interpersonal and hybrid courses as well. The videos noted here might also prove useful to interject periodically throughout a course in nonverbal/interpersonal/human communication.
 

Creating a Video of Nonverbal Communication

 

An excellent experience for learning about nonverbal communication is to teach it. Consequently, a popular assignment in many nonverbal communication courses is to create a video to teach some aspect of nonverbal communication. You might then upload it to YouTube or some similar site, exchange videos with others, and critique each other’s videos.

There are numerous websites that illustrate and demonstrate the ways to go about making a video. For example, http://www.youtube.com/create offers a variety of suggestions for creating a video. And, of course, there are a variety of websites that will help you film, design, and edit your video. Just search for “video design,” “create video,” or similar terms and you’ll find the most recent videos on creating videos. These websites and their accompanying videos—as well as all the videos you’ve already watched--will provide a lot better instruction than any print description could.  

In addition to the suggestions you’ll find online, consider these as well.

1.      Keep your video short—aim for 2 minutes. This will force you to compact your ideas but still treat a single idea in some depth. 

2.      Clarify the purpose you want to achieve. Do you want to illustrate specific gestures or an interaction? Do you want to compare nonverbals in different cultures? Once you’ve formulated your purpose, you’ll be better able to select appropriate ways of creating your video.

3.      Select the appropriate means for achieving your purpose. So, for example, if you want to illustrate different gestures in different cultures, then you’ll likely need members of both cultures to demonstrate the gestures or you’ll need photos or graphics.

4.      Keep your subject limited. Don’t try to cover too much. For your first nonverbal communication video, consider focusing on one code and illustrating one aspect of that code—for example, if you want to focus on touch, then you might limit your video to, say, relationship touching. Or, if you want to focus on gestures, you might limit your video to adaptors or illustrators. The idea here is to cover a limited topic but in some depth rather than a broad topic in only general terms.

5.      If you use PowerPoint or Prezi slides, keep them simple. Viewers are not likely to read slides with too much information on them. Similarly don’t crowd the slides with visual images. Use additional slides rather than crowd them.

6.      Keep it professional. You may find it useful to add this video to your resume should you want employers to see it. Of course, if it’s on a public site, prospective employers are very likely to see it whether you want them to or not.

7.      Here is a list of nonverbal communication videos that you can use as examples of the varied types of videos you might create. It should prove useful to review some of these with the idea of your doing your own video. What are some of the pitfalls that you’d want to avoid? What are some of the clever techniques that you might want to adapt?

These videos vary widely in just about every conceivable way. Some are quite professional and sophisticated in terms of production while others are the works of beginners with little technical equipment. Some are basically informational—those produced by colleges and narrated by professors, for example—while others are promotional for books or seminars. Some are designed to sell a product and others are designed to fulfill a requirement in a communication course. Some of the videos make well-substantiated claims, the kinds of conclusions you find in your nonverbal communication textbooks and research articles. Others, however, make claims beyond what most academics would accept. For example, if you just watched the videos you’d come away with the idea that you can read a person like a book. Of course, you can’t.

I’ve tried to group these into a few categories though most of the videos vary over several nonverbal codes. The categories used here simply reflect the videos I found that I thought would be useful. Most of the videos are short—the longest is 11 minutes, 23 second and the shortest is 32 seconds. The average is probably around 4 minutes.



 

GENERAL

 

General introduction to NVC


 

what is nonverbal communication? Nonverbal communication, vocal cues and facial expressions 3 min, 01 sec


 

Movie clips showing varied forms of nonverbal communication, 2.58


 

Deborah Borisoff and others on nonverbal communication—general, 3.01http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07AufHZygjs

 

Doctor-Patient nonverbal communication, 7.19 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRE7f52bS7w

 

Candidates/campaigning and body language effectiveness http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3yy5eIJW2Y&feature=related

 

Power and nonverbal communication, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cS1LI_ut3fs

Interpersonal Conflict, 4min 32 sec


 

 

PERCEPTION/ATTRACTION/FIRST IMPRESSIONS

 

Perception of Beauty 1 mn, 15 sec. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAnRQncZ_uk

 

The factors that make for attraction, 11 min, 23 sec


 

what makes a man attractive to women?


 

body language and attraction 2.25. A series of images depicting various forms of body language that communicate attraction


 

measuring beauty, 2.58


 

 

CULTURE

 

For a discussion of cultural differences in gestures. 5min, 19 sec


 

The use of silence in Japan, 7.11


 

Cultural dimensions, Hofstede, 2.09


 

A discussion of Hofstede’s cultural dimensions


 

Touch behavior in different cultures, 3.39


 


NVC in Brazilian culture, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zTgPMkFWDlQ, 3.09


NVC and culture, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyPhAeZcsvY, 5.24--general

NVC and South Korean Culture, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFQFp05Twww, 4.31

NVC gestures and cultures, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BM9Iu4OQXAw, 5.17




Polish and Japanese gestures, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi6h8zktO1s, 1.41

Colombian hand gestures, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QDEAPV73v4s, 1.12

Hand gestures in various cultures with subtitles identifying the varied meanings, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHSe1ogHYUw, 3.24

Maria Baltar talks about greeting rituals in different cultures, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vMskROH6v6U, 7.30

Dan Fishel from the Columbia Business School talks about the American handshake, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDhXD25fmMo, 4.42

 

DECEPTION

 


Lying, spotting deception, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6WFvcZnokKE, 8.15

Lying in the beginning of relationships, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcBsRbT4vLQ, 3.28

James Pennebaker on deception and words—a useful addition to most of the nonverbal stuff on deception—(discusses and shows tapes of Representative Anthony Weiner who lied and then told the truth about sending sexual photos, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vc073RIC7_M, 2.33

Suggests there are 3 ways to tell if someone is lying to you, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWQtuXSnXtU, 7.22

Social behavior and etiquette—signs of lying 1 min, 59 sec. Discusses some of the popular beliefs about deception detection


Jan Hargrave talks about deception and aims to teach you how to tell what others are thinking through observing nonverbal communication. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5X7fKZTmZa4&feature=results_main&playnext=1&list=PLD0D3AA38EE11B8D4, 9.34

 

EFFECTIVENESS IN INTERVIEWING, DATING

 

Simple word charts with voice over on first impressions (both verbal and nonverbal), offers the standard advice but very well phrased, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqiIXOpH-BA, 1.23

Staged interactions of job interviews with some good advice on nonverbal communication, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I5Cy1yf9wwQ, 9.28

Suggestions for speed dating, both verbal and nonverbal, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P43aALpN1UY, 2.28

Suggestions for making a good first impression, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOGFmFRJ2xA, 1.19

Discussion of suggestions for more effective body language in dating, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKx--9CG0fY, 5.44

Interview with Barbara Roberts on face reading and especially if you can tell when someone is dangerous solely from face reading, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpgM2tbCUMQ&feature=results_video&playnext=1&list=PLD0D3AA38EE11B8D4, 5.47

Professor Gary Deaton talks about posture and gesture in a job interview, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bNSsfDfy2Q, 3.52

Nick Morgan talks about how speakers are evaluated by the way they stand and walk to the stage, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIdttrC0xtM, 2.02

 

SPECIFIC CODES (touch, gestures, smell, etc.)

 

A short video on tracking eye movements to study consumer behavior 2 min, 44 sec


 

Touch Avoidance 1. 29


 

On color communication, 1.56


 

On color communication, 1.56


 

Silence—puts forth examples of when silence is destructive


 

Chronemics: Polychronic v. Monocrhonic time orientations, 10.41. Show a variety of people with different time orientations


 

Monochronicity v. polychronicity, 3.07


 

Proxemics—the close talker from Seinfeld, .47


 

Nonverbal proxemic violations, 4.54


 

Eye contact, 1.44


 

on the silent treatment, cartoon character talks about the problems with the silent treatment 5.53


 

Rate of speech from a sales training point of view 6.13. “Listenable rate of speech”


 

a humorous monotone speaker 1.16


 

Clothing and communication, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNJ7zfMd2fw, 2.02

Clothing—do clothes make the man?, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wg7eqQ3QTYI, 3.05 with some good historical notes

Sales tips on dressing for your prospects, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=feMK9Kr1yDc, 2.20

Cathrine Hatcher talks about color as communication, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUefDi65d6I, 5.48

An ad for Old Spice that illustrates the importance of smell, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FgGVXhya6hk, .32

 

 

Monday, August 27, 2012

Cultural Awareness

Here's an interesting little piece, sent to me by the author, on using cartoons to teach children cultural awareness and sensitivity. The 10 ways are easily adaptable to feature films, adult cartoons, and television shows for use with college students.
http://www.nationalnannies.com/blog/10-ways-cartoons-help-kids-learn-about-different-cultures/

Sunday, August 12, 2012

Nonverbal Communication Exercise


Here is a brief exercise that I used in teaching nonverbal communication and that I rewrote for a textbook in nonverbal that I’m in the process of writing. Here I use it as an introduction to the discussion of height but it can also be used with perception, stereotypes, and media influences, for example. You can adjust it in any way you’d like for your own classes.

Before reading about/discussing height, try your hand at estimating the heights of famous people that you’ve probably read about, heard about, and perhaps seen in photographs and film portrayals, but not face-to-face. Estimate their heights (in feet and inches) simply on the basis of the image you have of these people.

1.      Baby Face Nelson (bank robber and murderer in the 1930s) __________.

2.      Ludwig Van Beethoven (influential German composer) __________.

3.      Bonnie Parker (gangster of the 1920s and 1930s, part of the Barrow Gang) __________.

4.      Buckminister Fuller (scientist, credited with inventing the geodesic dome) __________.

5.      Clyde Barrow (gangster of the 1920s and 1930s, leader of the Barrow Gang) __________.

6.      Mahatma Gandhi (Indian political leader whose civil disobedience led to India’s independence from British rule) __________.

7.      James Madison (fourth President of the US, largely credited with writing the Constitution _______.

8.      Joan of Arc (military leader, burned for heresy at 19, and declared a Saint) __________.

9.      T. E. Lawrence [of Arabia] (adventurer and British Army officer) __________.

10.  Pablo Picasso (influential Spanish artist) __________.

This was designed to see if you would overestimate the heights of a good majority of these people. Fame seems to be associated with height and so most people would think these people were taller than they really were. The specific heights are as follows: Baby Face Nelson: 5’5”; Ludwig Van Beethoven 5’6”; Bonnie Parker: 4’10”; Buckminister Fuller: 5’2”; Clyde Barrow: 5’7”; Mahatma Gandhi: 5’3”; James Madison, 5’4”; Joan of Arc: 4’11”; T. E. Lawrence: 5’5”; Picasso: 5’4”;