Friday, February 15, 2008

Mimicry, persuasion, and pro-social behavior

This article reports on the persuasiveness of simple mimicry; if you mimic another individual's nonverbal behavior, you're likely to be more persuasive than if you didn't mimic. In addition, mimicry seems to increase pro-social behavior even for those not involved in the mimicry interaction; that is, if someone mimics you, you're more likely to engage in some pro-social behavior. As you can imagine, an understanding of mimicry can be useful for the person attempting to persuade as well as for the critical listener. And, of course, recognize that mimicry when taken to the extreme can backfire and be perceived as insulting. There's a great deal of research on this; just search for "mimicry" or "behavioral contagion" or "communication accommodation."

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

The Impostor

Some years ago, one of the most interesting concepts advanced was that of the impostor [or imposter] phenomenon—which, briefly, refers to the psychological syndrome in which one feels like a failure and a fake in spite of outward appearances of success. The titles of two of the books at that time further explain this belief: Cynthia Katz, If I’m so Successful, Why Do I feel Like a Fake? (St. Martins, 1985) and Pauline Rose Clance, The Impostor Phenomenon: Overcoming the Fear that Haunts Your Success (Peachtree, 1985). Now, however, according to some research (reported in the Science Times, NYTimes, 2/5/08): “many self-styled impostors are phony phonies; they adopt self-deprecation as a social strategy [as a type of impression or identity management], consciously or not, and are secretly more confident than they let on.” The original article is: Kumar, S., & Jagacinski, C. M. (2006). Imposters have goals too. Personality and Individual Differences 40, 147-157.

Friday, February 1, 2008

Interpersonal Communication Exercise, Discourse Analysis

Here is an exercise that I think will prove effective around the middle of the semester, with the coverage of conversation, or perhaps at the end of the semester. It might even be useful right at the beginning of the course to illustrate some of the ways we talk about interpersonal communication. The general purpose of this exercise is to clarify the concepts and principles discussed throughout the course and to illustrate how these can be identified in and applied to specific interpersonal interactions. As with all material on this blog, feel free to use this as you wish; just include a credit note. If you do use it, I’d appreciate any reactions—good or bad—that you might have. I look at this as a work in progress and so anything you care to share would be helpful.

Discourse Analysis

The Exercise (in Brief):
This exercise focuses on analyzing interpersonal discourse in terms of the concepts and principles discussed throughout an interpersonal course and textbook.

The Procedures:
(1) Read through the dialogues presented below and select one for analysis. Try to get a picture of what is going on.
(2) Review the list of 100+ terms presented below and select those terms that you feel describe the interpersonal communication going on in the dialogue. Then try one or more of these suggestions:
• In small groups or with the class as a whole, explain your discourse analysis. Explain why the terms you selected describe the interaction. This process should help clarify some of the ways in which messages are perceived and why some are more effective than others.
• Rewrite one of the dialogues to reflect more effective patterns of interpersonal communication and, using the terms provided here or others you find more relevant, explain (in small groups or with the class as a whole) why the rewritten version is, in fact, more effective. This process should help distinguish effective from ineffective discourse and illustrate ways to make your own interpersonal communication more effective and more satisfying.
• Small groups can each take a different dialogue, analyze the discourse, and report their findings back to the larger group.

The Dialogues:
Admittedly these are overly short so feel free to fill in any additional dialogue you think would be consistent with each of the characters. As an alternative to using these dialogues, you might use one or more interactions from a film; television drama or sitcom; print, online, or televised interview; or commercial (see blog post for January 8, 2008, Dysfunctional Relationships, for some examples of suitable commercials). If different groups selected sequential scenes from the same movie, it could be used to illustrate how characters are developed and presented to the audience through their verbal and nonverbal interpersonal communication messages—admittedly, a purpose somewhat off the beaten path.


The Student, the Teacher, and the Parent
Seven-year-old child arriving home from school: I hate that teacher; I can’t stand that school.
Parent: O.K., now what did you do? I’d better not have to go to another parent-teacher conference.

The Couple
Partner 1 arriving home with a box of Danish pastry. I just went out and got us some Danish; we can have them with our coffee.
Partner 2: Don’t you ever listen to me? I’m trying to lose some weight; I can’t eat that.

Helping a Friend
Friend 1: You got to help me out. You’ve got to tell Pat I was working late last night with you.
Friend 2: You don’t think I’m not going to lie for you, do you?

The New College Students
College Student 1 (Chris): Hi, Pat. I see the New Students reception is on Saturday. Would you like to go together?
College Student 2 (Pat): No, not really.
Chris: Aren’t you going?
Pat: Yeah, I’m going but I’m not sure who I’m going with. I may go with C.J. or with Mel.
Chris: You’re all in the same dorm?
Pat: No, not really.

The Parents
Mother or Father: Your child got into trouble at school today.
Mother or Father: What’s the big deal this time? Chewing gum?

Serious Dating Partners
Dating Partner 1: So I went out with my ex. So, big deal! We’re friends.
Dating Partner 2: Well, that has to stop. I’m not going to have people see me as your second choice.

Sibling Conflict
Sibling 1: Can I wear your new sweater tonight? I have a really important date.
Sibling 2: You always want to wear my clothes. Why don’t you just buy your own. And anyway I think I’m going to wear the sweater tonight myself.

Terms for Describing Interpersonal Interactions:
Here are 100+ terms that may be used to describe interpersonal communication—a mixture of communication jargon and popular expressions. These are certainly not the only concepts and principles you might use; feel free to select others if you feel they would be more relevant and revealing.

Abusive, Accommodating, Accusatory, Active, Active and inactive listening, Affinity seeking, Affirmative, Aggressive, Ambiguous, Angry, Argumentative, Assertive, Attentive, Avoiding, Belittling, Beltlining, Caring, Clear, Closed, Cold, Collaborative, Competent, Competing, Complimentary, Compromising, Concerned, Confirming, Conflict generating, Confrontational, Constructive, Content focused, Cooperative, Critical, Critical listening, Crude, Culturally insensitive, Culturally sensitive, Deceptive, Defensive, Demanding, Demoralizing, Depth listening, Dialogic, Direct, Disclosive, Disconfirming, Dishonest, Distant, Dogmatic, Double binding, Emotional, Empathic, Empathic listening, Equal, Ethical, Evaluative, Excluding, Expressive, Extensional, Face saving, Face threatening, Feminine, Formal, Friendly, Gunnysacking, Helpful, High monitored, Honest, Hostile, I-message, Immediate, Impersonal, Impolite, Including, Incompetent, Inconsiderate, Indifferent, Indirect, Informal, Insensitive, Insulting, Insulting, Intensional, Intimate, Judgmental, Logical, Loving, Low monitored, Manipulative, Masculine, Mindful, Mindless, Mixed, Monologic, Negative, Negative, Neutral, Nonimmediate, Nonjudgmental listening, Objective, Objective listening, Open, Other oriented, Passive, Perceptive, Personal, Polarizing, Polite, Positive, Present focused, Rejecting, Relationship focused, Satisfying, Sensitive, Stereotypical, Superior, Supportive, Surface listening, Tension producing, Trusting, Truthful, Unassertive, Uncaring, Unconcerned, Understanding, Unethical, Unsatisfying, Warm, You-message

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Some Advantages of Relationship Dissolution

For a variety of reasons—some religious, some social, some economic, some interpersonal, and perhaps some based on an analysis of costs and benefits—people feel that relationships should last and that it’s bad when they end. And so you often respond positively when a couple says they’ve been together for a long period of time and respond with sadness and “I’m sorry” or “that’s too bad” when you hear they’re breaking up. Researchers and textbook authors seem to echo this popular belief. I can’t seem to find this topic in any of the interpersonal communication texts.
Upon more sober reflection, however, it should be clear that there are many advantages to relationship dissolution. Often, the relationship deserves to be dissolved. So, this brief post is in the nature of a suggestion to researchers, textbook authors, instructors, and interpersonal-relationship-watchers to look more carefully at relationship dissolution, particularly its advantages. It’s easy to come up with lots of examples from friendship, love, and even family that illustrate the advantages of relationship dissolution.
Friendships may become destructive or overly competitive—as they might in a variety of work situations—and may be better put aside. When a “friend” makes your self-disclosures public or otherwise betrays your confidence and this becomes a pattern that’s repeated over and over again, it may be time to move from the level of friendship to that of seldom-seen acquaintanceship. When a “friend” just uses you and gives nothing in return, it may be time to dissolve.
Romantic relationships—whether dating, married, domestic partnership, or any other such relationship—may become unbalanced, where one person does all the work and the other reaps all the benefits. Some romantic relationships may become verbally or physically abusive (or the abusiveness reaches an intolerable level) and in these cases, the relationship may be better dissolved.
Even in families, certain members or relationships within the family may become toxic. Partners, parents, or children often become enablers, helping a family member to engage in destructive behavior—for example, helping to hide the alcoholism from friends and relatives and thus helping the partner to continue drinking more comfortably and without social criticism. Gay and lesbian children who are rejected by their families after coming out, may be better off away from homophobic (and guilt-instilling) parents, siblings, and assorted relatives. And the same can be said for a son or daughter who forms a permanent relationship with someone the family disapproves of and will not accept. In this case, a decision of loyalty and primary affiliation may have to be made between family and relationship partner. In at least some of these decisions, greater long-term satisfaction would be achieved by severing family ties rather than abandoning a productive and happy romantic relationship.
When the primary purposes that a friendship, romantic relationship, or family relationship serve are not met, then the relationship is not serving the purposes for which you entered it (or were born into, in the case of family). It may be time to consider the advantages of ending the relationship.
The examples used above should not imply that one of the individuals has to be doing something wrong for dissolution to be an appropriate course of action—although it is easier to see the logic of dissolution when one of the individuals betrays a trust or is unfaithful or becomes abusive. But, there are legitimate reasons for dissolution even when neither party has done anything wrong. People may develop different needs during their relationship together that cannot be met within the confines of the present relationship. Likewise, changes in interests and goals, recognition of one’s true affectional orientation, or finding a greater love may all be legitimate reasons for relationship dissolution. Relationship dissolution should not imply that someone did something wrong; there is no reason to assume that it’s necessary for someone to do something wrong to warrant dissolving a relationship.
Conversely, it should not be assumed that because people stay together there is something noble about them or about their relationship. Long-lasting relationships are not necessarily better than relationships of short duration. We need not praise long lasting relationships, nor condemn short relationships. The length of time people stay in a relationship actually says little about the nature of the relationship. Dramatic examples of this are seen daily on Jerry Springer and Maury where people are in long-term relationships that most people would find repulsive. Less dramatic examples are likely to be found everywhere else.
And, of course, there are general benefits that need to be written into the equation. One obvious benefit is that you rid yourself of destructive influences; there seems little point in retaining relationships that are unproductive, unhealthy, and hurtful. Another benefit is that you probably have learned something from the experience that you can then apply to new and, ideally at least, more satisfying and more productive relationships. And, hopefully, you probably have had some time to get to know yourself a lot better.
At the same time, it needs to be recalled that we enter relationships for a variety of reasons and it may be worth the effort to repair the relationship to get back what we had originally. The difficulty with this “theory” is that we can never be sure if and when, in the face of repeated failures at attempts to repair the relationship, the next attempt wouldn’t succeed. So, at some point, it may be best to say, “I tried and now I need to move on.” Treating relationships as if they can be easily and appropriately discarded is unlikely to yield long-term benefits. Perhaps equally unlikely to yield long-term benefits, is remaining in unproductive and destructive relationships.
The decision to stay in a relationship that does not fulfill your needs or is destructive or to end the relationship is not an easy one to make, since so many factors come into play. Religious beliefs, the attitudes of family members and close friends, and the economic implications of staying together versus separating are just a few of the more obvious factors that would logically influence such decisions.

Monday, January 14, 2008

Public Speaking Eloquence

Here's an interesting article from yesterday's New York Times. It should provide a neat bridge between the public speaking course and the election rhetoric. It also contains some interesting observations from communication profs Kathleen Hall Jamieson and David Zarefsky.

Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Dysfunctional Relationships

One of the themes in commercials, at least recently, seems to be the dysfunctional relationship.
In one commercial, for T-Mobile, a dating couple (at least they look like they’re dating) go shopping. She asks him for his opinion on two dresses, two pairs of shoes, and two sets of earrings. In each case, he indicates his preference and she rejects it, selecting the other choice. He then uses this insight to get the phone color he wants. So, in addition to learning that you have color choices--which is the pitch of this particular commercial—the message also seems to be saying that dishonest questions are the rule of the day, and that deception, deceit, and disconfirmation are all part of the dating and relationship experience.
In another phone commercial—this one for Verizon—the father tells everyone in the family that each is No. 1 and then, when alone, acknowledges that he is “numero uno.” So, in addition to telling the viewer that Verizon has certain capabilities, the commercial also communicates the suggestion to tell people what they want to hear (even members of your own family) and then just go on your merry way.
In a Domino’s Pizza commercial a couple is waiting for delivery. The man, trying to look his sexiest, says we have 30 minutes to delivery and asks if she has any ideas as to how to spend the time. Her response: What will we do with the other 28 minutes? If anyone wants a lesson in how to make his or her partner feel totally inadequate, this commercial will tell you how to do it. The woman is made to look unsupportive, critical, and extremely negative; the man is made to look like an unresponsive fool.
In still another commercial, one for Fidelity Investments, a couple is talking about retirement planning. The husband is trying to act knowledgeable but the wife knows and shows in no uncertain terms that he really knows nothing about finance. She makes her life partner of maybe 30 or 40 years look like a complete imbecile and seems to enjoy the experience. So, in addition to making the point that Fidelity Investments does everything for you, the commercial perpetuates the stereotypes of the incompetent man and the nagging woman and tells us what to expect in a relationship—criticism, one person putting down the other, and an inability or unwillingness to relate in any meaningful way.
I assume that these commercials do persuade some people to buy the product and that some people do find these funny—otherwise, I guess, they wouldn’t be on television and the company wouldn’t be spending millions to air them. Exactly why these commercials are effective or why they are thought funny, however, is not at all clear to me. But, I am convinced that these commercials contribute at least somewhat to teaching viewers about relationships— the way to disconfirm and manipulate your relationship partner, the way you can insult and demoralize your partner, and the kinds of antagonistic relationships you can expect to have.
I suspect a useful interpersonal communication exercise could easily be developed around the search for gender stereotypes, compliance-gaining, confirmation and disconfirmation, relationship conflict, ethics, and a variety of other concepts and principles in television, print, and Internet commercials. Perhaps some commercials can be found that offer more productive and functional relationship examples. It would be nice.

Friday, January 4, 2008

Social Networking

There's an interesting article in Thursday's NYTimes on the social networking sites and especially how people manage the impressions they communicate. A variety of communication researchers are cited. Among the most interesting of the findings is that the atrractiveness of your friends on Facebook will influence how attractive people think you are. If you have attractive friends, you'll be perceived as more attractive than you would if you had less attractive friends. Of course, we already knew that--you need A-list friends if you're going to be seen as A-list yourself. But, it's interesting to see that this also holds in cyberspace. Joe Walther, communication professor from Michigan State, did the study which will be published in HCR. The article will make for interesting class discussion on impression formation and social networking.